Never Loan Books (or DVDs, for that matter)
There was a brief, but poignant moment in the new Battlestar Galactica series where Adama and Roslin are talking about something or another, and in the interest of diplomacy, Adama gives Roslin a novel he thinks she would enjoy. When Roslin begins to demure about returning it, Adama tells her, "It's a gift. Never loan books." Good advice.
Books are easily damageable through normal use, so loaning a book means almost never getting it back in the same shape you loaned it out in. Even when the borrower is careful, accidents happen. My copy of a reference manual is twice its original thickness thanks to a roofing leak at the home of a colleague who had borrowed it for only a few days. Then again, some people are intentionally careless or rough. On getting some books back from a friend that had been thoroughly manhandled, he flippantly replied that the books didn't look used and needed to be broken in. For some reason, my obsessive tendencies shut down and now it's no big deal. Of course, when another friend loaned this guy a book, I secretly reveled in his misery he experienced on getting the creased and beaten copy back.
These days, if I really enjoy a book, I'm likely to pick up a "loaner" copy which I can casually share around to those I think would also appreciate the book. Who knows how many copies of The Poisonwood Bible I've bought?
Anyway, that all brings us to DVDs. At first appearance, DVD loaning is much safer than books. You really have to go out of your way to damage a DVD. The inserts and covers are all protected by plastic, and if the case gets broken, well, DVD cases are easily replaceable. No, the risk of DVD loaning is the most basic risk, that of outright loss. Sometimes its no big deal; DVDs are cheap to start with, and just a couple of months, most mainstream movies drop in price by half.
Among our friends, we've been sharing DVDs left and right, and as long as you can't catch Asian Bird Flu from that, I think it's a great thing. I get to see good movies that have been prescreened by people whose opinions I trust, and in return, I get someone to talk with about movies I like. It all works great, until we begin to forgot who had what and who what belongs to. Lately, things have been going slightly worse than usual, with more lost and misappropriated discs than usual.
Poor Dave has gotten it worse than most of us. In addition to his Galaxy Quest, and Spider-man, he is also short one copy of Hands on a Hardbody, the great documentary about an endurance contest at a truck dealership in Longview, TX. It's a fun movie, and its rarity makes it popular in our circle. Seeing it used to be a rite of passage. Unfortunately one person too many borrowed it, and now it's gone. Just gone. The real tragedy is that the film is out of print, meaning that copies on eBay go for ridiculous prices. (I have difficulty believing that those copies actually sell for the prices they're asking, except possibly on speculation.) And just so you don't think I'm completely blameless, I'm the last person anybody remembers having the disc, though I'm sure I returned it. I promise! To make matters worse, I had his copy of Running Out of Time for nearly two years.
I think I'm doing better than most, though. I went through and organized my DVD collection and found the only major disc I was missing, My Beautiful Girl, Mari. I had loaned it, Tokyo Marigold, Swallowtail Butterfly, and Memento Mori to Dave, and he said that he had returned it, but that he had not returned Memento Mori and still had to watch Swallowtail and Marigold. But the fate of Mari was a mystery up until just last night. I found the disc with some unrelated films, which suggests that I just threw it in the box when I was cleaning up in a hurry a while back. I kind of feel bad that I had been riding Dave about it, when I had it the whole time. Just to show you I don't learn my lesson, it's getting loaned out again when we return to school after spring break.
On the plus side, I'm finding duplicates of movies that must have come back from people I didn't loan them to. Right now, I have two copies of The Iron Giant and The Transporter, only one of each is mine. (Don't ask why I bought The Transporter. I simply didn't know at the time.) One of them came from my sister, I think, so it probably belonged to one of her friends, but nobody in either of our circles has claimed it, so it's probably ours now. The Iron Giant, however, came from a friend of ours who is (a) very organized and (b) takes care of our friends' children, so somebody loaned her this as a kids movie, I'm sure, and somehow it came back to me. I've only just started trying to track this one down, so who knows who it belongs to?